When you buy through our links, we might earn money from our affiliate partners. Find Out More.

online meat comparison


Omaha Steaks/Instagram.

As passionate carnivores and amateur house cooks, we have actually evaluated a range of online meat shipment services that source high-quality meat, send them securely to your house, and reveal you the best methods to prepare them. After many cooking, grilling, and tasting sessions, we have actually found that 3 business stand apart above the rest: Porter Roadway, ButcherBox, and Omaha Steaks

Though they all provide the same standard service, they differ in cuts provided, where the meat is sourced, pricing, delivery frequency, and other aspects. We like all 3, however one may better suit your tastes and choices, so we compared their significant distinctions listed below.

Porter Road ButcherBox Omaha Steaks
Offerings Meat (beef, pork, lamb, chicken) Meat (beef, pork, chicken) Meat, seafood, sides, desserts
Style À la carte cuts and subscriptions Membership just À la carte cuts and subscriptions
Rate $ 9-$140 $149-$270 Varies extensively
Shipping Free on orders over $100 Free on all orders $1799-$2199

Keep reading for all the details between Porter Roadway, ButcherBox, and Omaha Steaks

Porter Roadway

porter road

Porter Road.


Order meat from Porter Road here

Read our review of Porter Roadway here

What it sells: Pasture-raised, no hormone- or antibiotic-added beef, pork, lamb, and chicken.

How it works: Choose from curated packages like the six-pound Grill Master Load($70, waitlist only), or produce your own box by filling it with the cuts and quantities you want.

Rate: Packages can vary from $70 to $127, à la carte cuts vary from $9 ( hamburger) to $140( entire tenderloin, waitlist only)

Shipping: Free basic shipping is used on orders over $100 and your order of individually packaged cuts will get here cold in an insulated box.

Why you might like it:

  • Modification and option: If you have specific preferences in mind, you can filter by cooking time and cooking equipment to find the most appropriate cuts. Porter Roadway provides a large variety of cuts, from the familiar to the underrated, enabling you to blend and match the supreme shopping basket of meat.
  • Plain education: On each item information page, you can learn what part of the animal the cut originates from and the best method to prepare it.
  • Optimized online experience: The site and images are laid out beautifully. It’s enjoyable and easy to shop through the site, which is a deserving spin-off of the initial Nashville butcher shop.


butcherbox thumb



How it works: There are 5 different membership strategies: all beef, beef and chicken, beef and pork, a blended box of all three types, and a custom-made box.

  • Automatic but flexible shipment: It’s a membership service, with boxes provided every month or every two months.
  • Omaha Steaks

    online meat comparison 2

    Omaha Steaks/Instagram.


    Shipping: Requirement shipping costs $17

    Why you may like it:

    • Large product selection: Though its name states “Steaks” and its strength is certainly beef, you can basically go shopping for your whole dinner here, down to flavorings and specialized desserts


    You can buy syndication rights to this story here.

    Disclosure: This post is brought to you by the Expert Evaluations team. We highlight products and services you may discover interesting. If you purchase them, we get a little share of the income from the sale from our commerce partners. We frequently receive items complimentary of charge from manufacturers to test. This does not drive our decision as to whether a product is included or suggested. We run independently from our advertising sales team. We invite your feedback. Email us at reviews@businessinsider.com.


    Loading Something is filling.


    Expert Picks 2020
    delivery service

    Chevron icon It shows an expandable area or menu, or in some cases previous/ next navigation alternatives.